I’m part of a big discussion etc group on GoodReads (I love GoodReads it is my fave). We were talking about Gone Girl and the nature of abusive relationships. The part of the conversation that I was involved in focused on mother-child relationships.
From my own experience, a behavior that you learned – your mother abusing you – makes it more likely that you, as a mother, will abuse your own child. A couple of people vociferously argued against this point. I agree with them, and I disagree with them.
I consider that a lot of my mother’s behavior towards me was abusive. I feel angry that she acted this way towards me. I feel angry that she didn’t care enough about her children – this is my emotional perception – to be more kind, to get help and treatment, to change her behavior, to get herself under control. So, yes,it doesn’t matter what kind of parenting you experienced as a child, you should make every change possible and CHOOSE to be a different person, not to abuse your own children.
But then I think about my relationship with my husband (bear with me; I agree he is not my child). The primary example of marriage that I have is my parents’ marriage, which, while I was growing up, did not seem very happy. I remember a lot of sniping and fight-picking on my mother’s side; I remember feeling sad that no matter what my father did or said, no matter how kind and loving he was, it was not enough for my mother and made her even more angry at him. Tried to load the dishwasher after dinner – yelled at for not doing it correctly. That kind of thing.
And, again, I see my relationship with my husband, and I act the same way that my mother does. I do not want to do it. I want to show love. I want to be a person who loves. But the only model that I have for “how to wife” is not a good one. And I nitpick, and I start arguments about loading the dishwasher.
I know I am mean, I know this is bad behavior. Oh, I know. I acknowledge and apologize and ask forgiveness. But in the moment, I literally do not understand how to act differently. I do not understand what it means to CHOOSE to act differently. I do not understand how to recognize that there IS any other way to act. This is why I am in therapy, and have been for some time.
So I think learned behavior has more of a place in abuse than that discussion partner understands. In those heated moments, you run on instinct, your emotions completely eat your brain, and you ACT. It happens. The words fly out of your mouth at incredible speeds. It is so hard to stop them, and I fail more than I succeed. This is also why I do not want to be a mother. I do not want to submit a child to the awful behavior I know I would exhibit, even if only for a short period of time. I think that what I learned then is too strong, and experimenting on that hypothetical child would be too cruel.